A Dubai court has ordered a husband and his son to jointly pay Dh16.1 million to the man's wife after they were convicted of stealing gold and diamond jewellery, luxury watches and cash from her home during a marital dispute. The stolen valuables, which included more than 100 pieces of jewellery, were valued at Dh15.1 million.
The Dubai Court of First Instance ordered the two defendants to repay Dh15.1 million, representing the value of the stolen property, and awarded the woman an additional Dh1 million for material and moral damage. The civil ruling followed criminal proceedings in which both men were convicted of theft and sentenced to one year in prison each.
According to court records, the theft occurred amid ongoing disagreements between the husband and wife. The husband and his son took more than 100 pieces of gold and diamond jewellery, along with luxury watches and cash, from the woman's residence.
The case was initially heard by a criminal court, which found both defendants guilty of theft. Each received a one-year prison sentence, while the court also imposed a joint fine of Dh15.1 million, equivalent to the estimated value of the stolen possessions.
The criminal convictions were subsequently upheld by the Court of Appeal, establishing the defendants' responsibility for the theft. The woman later pursued separate civil proceedings to recover the value of her belongings and seek compensation for the losses and distress she had experienced.
Wife sought Dh50 million in compensation
In her civil lawsuit, the woman demanded Dh50 million, arguing that the theft had deprived her of valuable property and caused considerable psychological suffering. She said the incident had also prevented her from benefiting financially from the jewellery during the period it remained outside her possession.
The woman claimed that gold prices had increased by at least 70% since the theft, resulting in potential lost profits of approximately Dh11 million. She argued that the appreciation in gold prices should be considered when calculating the financial damage she had suffered.
She also sought approximately Dh23.9 million for emotional and moral damage, citing the distress caused by the involvement of her husband and his son in the theft and the consequences of pursuing legal action against them.
During the civil proceedings, the court considered the final criminal judgment, which had already established that the defendants were responsible for stealing the woman's property. The remaining question was the amount of compensation justified by the evidence and applicable legal principles.
The court found that the woman had been deprived of her valuables and the opportunity to benefit from them for more than 18 months. It also acknowledged the psychological distress and inconvenience she experienced while seeking to recover her property through legal proceedings.
However, the court rejected her claim for anticipated profits arising from the increase in gold prices. It determined that compensation must be based on actual and established losses rather than hypothetical financial gains that might have been achieved if the jewellery had remained in her possession.
The court consequently ordered the husband and his son to jointly pay Dh15.1 million for the stolen property and an additional Dh1 million in compensation for the material and moral damage suffered by the woman.
The remaining compensation claims were dismissed, bringing the total civil award to Dh16.1 million. The ruling distinguished between the proven value of the stolen assets, the damage established during the proceedings and the speculative profits claimed from subsequent changes in gold prices.